Newsletter
    Popcentral
    Stay up to date

    Life is not a bed of roses. Reality, as Thanos famously said, is often disappointing. That’s why we turn to stories: books, films, comics, or any form of escape from the weight of everyday life. Yet increasingly, instead of solace, we’re being handed stories soaked in heartbreak. Tragedy, once a tool for emotional catharsis, is now a default setting.

    Modern storytelling has become addicted to the dopamine hit that comes with shock. Writers, it seems, are chasing virality, not vulnerability. There’s a certain god complex in building worlds where characters live and die on a whim. More often than not, death arrives not for narrative growth but for momentary impact. The result? A genre-wide desensitization. Moments that should break us now barely register.

    Take Game of Thrones. It once thrived on political complexity and rich character arcs. But by its final seasons, shock value had taken the wheel. Characters abandoned years of development. Iconic deaths felt unearned. Audiences were left not in awe but in apathy. A story that started as a masterclass in world-building collapsed into a spectacle without soul.

    This isn’t an isolated case. Think of The Last of Us Part II, where a beloved protagonist is brutally killed early on—not necessarily to drive the plot, but seemingly to provoke. Or Euphoria, where character suffering often feels more stylized than sincere. Even shows like The Handmaid’s Tale, once celebrated for its raw emotional depth, have leaned into endless brutality to keep audiences emotionally baited.

    I recently spoke to a Nigerian screenwriter who helped shape my understanding of this trend. He noted that when tragedy is done right, it doesn’t just sting—it stays. It lingers because it’s rooted in meaning. There’s a saying: tragedy begets the prettiest souls. It reveals character, tests belief, and pushes audiences to grapple with love, loss, and the fragility of hope.

    Shakespeare understood this. Romeo and Juliet isn’t just a love story. It’s a commentary on fate, family feuds, and the recklessness of youth. Its heartbreak is earned, deliberate, and deeply thematic. The tragedy matters. It doesn’t shock for the sake of shock. It elevates the story.

    But when suffering becomes a shortcut, when creators prioritize jaw-dropping deaths over emotional arcs, we lose something essential. The audience becomes numb. Instead of engaging deeply with characters, we anticipate the next twist, the next blow. We stop feeling. We start expecting.

    Why does this happen? Partly because shock sells. In an age of streaming wars and social media soundbites, being “talked about” often trumps being thoughtfully remembered. Death scenes trend. Unexpected betrayals go viral. As a result, creators lean into tragedy not as a narrative device but as a marketing tool.

    And yet, the best stories aren’t those that constantly surprise us. They’re the ones that stay with us. That move us. That reflect the human experience with empathy, not just edge. Not every story needs a happy ending. But not every story needs to leave us devastated either.

    Personally, I miss stories that breathe. That build slowly. That let joy and sorrow coexist. I want to be moved, not manipulated. Shock is fleeting. Resonance is forever.

    In a world obsessed with subverting expectations, perhaps the real twist is telling a story that dares to feel again. One where tragedy serves the soul of the narrative, not the algorithm.

    And if we’ve forgotten how to write that? Well, that in itself is a tragedy.

    Share.
    Leave A Reply